Field notes on things that run themselves
The Forest That Dies If You Save It
There are pine trees that keep their own seeds under lock and key for years, sometimes for decades, and hand the only copy of the key to a wildfire. The lock is a cone — not the dry, open cone you pick up on a trail, but one sealed shut with resin, its scales glued down over a full load of living seed, refusing to open in sun or wind or time. It opens in heat. When a fire sweeps through and the temperature at the cone climbs to somewhere around forty-five or fifty degrees Celsius, the resin softens, the scales lift, and the seed falls — not onto the shaded, crowded floor of the forest that was, but onto fresh ash, in open sun, with the competition just burned away. The tree has spent years timing the release of its seed to the one moment the ground is most ready to take it: the moment just after everything around it, very possibly including the parent tree, has burned.
Botanists call the trait serotiny, from the Latin for late, and it belongs to trees like the lodgepole pine of the western mountains and the jack pine of the northern woods. It is a strange wager. A serotinous tree pays, year after year, to hold a canopy full of seed it is not allowed to plant, and collects only when a fire kills the stand it grew in. These are not trees that merely tolerate fire; they have folded fire so deeply into their reproduction that without it the seed stays locked overhead and slowly dies there. A burned-over slope in Yellowstone can come back at tens of thousands of seedlings an acre, a whole even-aged forest springing up at once from a single afternoon’s release. Fire is not the disaster this forest survives. It is the event the forest is built around.
And it is not only the single tree. Step back, and the whole standing community turns out to be arranged around the burn — though forests, to be fair, place the bet in more than one way, and on very different clocks. The lodgepole waits, sometimes a century, for one catastrophic crown fire that flattens everything and clears the ground in a single stroke. The longleaf pine of the American Southeast does nearly the opposite: it courts fire constantly — every few years — but gently, low flames creeping through the grass. Its seedlings spend years in what’s called the grass stage, a stemless green tuft that looks stalled and is anything but, hiding a growing bud deep inside a dense, moist shock of needles while the surface fire slides past. What those frequent little fires buy the pine is room — they keep knocking back the oaks and other hardwoods that would otherwise shoot up, overtop the slow pines, and shade them out for good. Two opposite relationships with the same element, and underneath them the same dependence.
Some of the machinery is subtle enough that we only lately caught it. There are seeds — many chaparral shrubs, and fire-followers the world over — that lie dormant in the soil and germinate not to heat, and not to light, but to smoke: to the chemical trace of a fire that has just passed overhead and opened the canopy. For a long time no one knew what in the smoke they were reading. In 2004 a team in Western Australia pulled one of the key molecules out and named it karrikinolide, from karrik, the word for smoke in the language of the Noongar people whose country they were working on. It is potent past reason — some seeds respond to it at concentrations near a ten-billionth of a mole, a few stray molecules murmuring that the way above is finally clear. Smoke carries more than one such signal, nitrogen oxides among them, so karrikinolide isn’t the whole story. But the marvel holds: a seed can read the ash of its own parents’ forest and take it as the cue to begin.
All of which sets up the strangest fact in the arrangement: you can kill one of these forests by protecting it. For most of the twentieth century that is roughly what we did. Fire was the enemy, stamped out wherever it started — and wherever it was stamped out long enough, the fire-built forests began to come undone. Deny a longleaf savanna its burn and shade-tolerant hardwoods move in, overtop the young pines, and close the open canopy; the sunlit understory — which can hold as many as fifty species in a single square meter — thins toward a handful. On richer soils, a couple of decades of being spared is enough to turn a pine savanna into an ordinary hardwood forest. Meanwhile the fuel the small fires used to carry off just piles up, season on season, until the fire that does eventually come is not a renewing one but an annihilating one. Longleaf once spread across more than ninety million acres of the South; between logging and a century of fire exclusion it is down to something like four and a half million. The thing that looked like destruction had been doing the maintenance all along. Take it away, and the maintenance stops.
So the pattern that actually persists here is not any tree, and not any particular stand of them. Individual pines catch and burn and are replaced; the biomass grows in, burns off, grows in again. What keeps its shape across all of it is the community — the mix, the openness, the diversity — and it keeps that shape only because a disturbance sweeps through on an interval and redraws it. This series has been circling that thought for a while, but the last two issues found it inside a single cell: a cell digesting its own worn parts to conserve itself, a lymph node dissolving the very cells it spent so much to make. Here is the same unsentimental logic written across a landscape and a century instead of a cell and an afternoon — a standing thing kept standing by regular, load-bearing destruction, alive precisely because it is willing, on a schedule, to burn.
One loop I’m watching
Next: the needle of every compass on Earth points, without fail, at a magnetic field that nothing solid is holding up — a field generated a couple of thousand miles beneath your feet by an ocean of molten iron churning in the dark, and one that would quietly fade within a few thousand years if that churning ever stopped. A planet-sized standing wave, and the last thing you’d guess it was made of is motion.
Tip: the ← and → arrow keys move between issues.
Prefer feeds? Follow by RSS or JSON Feed.
Want something playable between issues? Thought Toys has its own email list and RSS feed.
New to The Standing Wave? Start here →